About 10 years ago, I was working at a church in Texas, going through an uncomfortable season of discernment about its future. I felt deeply emotionally invested in the outcome of the conversation, and (as a 24-year-old associate youth pastor) pretty powerless to shape it. I sat in a tense, 2-hour-long staff meeting, looking at the agenda printed in front of me, filling in all the spaces inside o’s and p’s and q’s. During the meeting, my boss’s boss decided to make a point to call on people he hadn’t heard from yet, and asked me if I had anything I wanted to add. I said, “No, I’m fine.”
“Really? Because your body language says you hate this.”
I suddenly noticed my own body: legs tucked up and over to the side, one foot fully in the chair; torso twisted towards my tucked-up legs, only a single hand touching the table so I could doodle on my agenda, also turned sideways to accommodate my contorted posture. He was right; my brain said I was fine with whatever decision the rest of the team made, but my body betrayed me, twisting itself into knots to force itself to be heard, even if that was by someone else.
In a meeting this week, Alice Fleming Townley, a brilliant member of our team, explained a technique she liked to use in her coaching based around what she called the “three centers of knowing” – the head, the heart, and the body.1 She suggested it as a response to a coachee who seemed to be saying the right things but whose heart wasn’t in it. She suggested we ask “What does your heart say to your head about that?” or “What would your body want to tell your head right now?” In our culture, it’s so often only our head that gets heard, when it so rarely holds the whole picture.
This misalignment between what our head knows, what our heart knows, and what our body knows is natural, and one is not always more right than the other. The technique Alice was highlighting was getting those centers of knowing inside a person to be in conversation with one another, to get a person to talk to themselves, and to listen to more than what their head has to say. As leaders, where do we see our own centers of knowing fall out of conversation with one another:
- When do we say the right thing to a parishioner or a committee, knowing in our heart we don’t mean it?
- When do we nod and smile to someone our brain tells us to be polite, when our body is telling us to run?
- When do we ignore the thing our heart says is what we really want, because our head says it’s impractical?
The conflict itself isn’t the issue; our hearts can be swayed by fictions, and our bodies are notoriously bad at mistaking the past for the present. But we have to hear ourselves out. We are always in negotiation inside ourselves; it’s the attempt to end the negotiation by silencing some of the voices completely that harms us. Those centers of wisdom have a tendency to make themselves heard in one way or another, and having some awkward body language in a meeting is about the least of our worries.2
As leaders, when we start to notice the centers of knowing in ourselves, we’ll see them in others as well:
- Where do we see people’s actions, words, body language betray a person at odds with themselves?
- Where do you see that internal conflict show up intrapersonally, interpersonally, spiritually, and organizationally?
- In what ways do we show preference for only what the head knows? In what ways do we engage the heart and the body’s way of knowing?
- What centers of knowing monopolize the room, and what centers of knowing are trying to make themselves heard?
This week, try to make space for all of your centers of knowing to join the conversation. Your body may not be right all the time (a piece of bad feedback is not actually life-threatening), and your heart might not be either (you don’t need to adopt another dog just because the ad had Sarah McGlaughlin in it), but they deserve to be heard in the conversation. You will likely find that you know more than you thought you did, and that the world God is creating around you, and calling you into, may be much more easily found using wisdom other than what’s in your head.
- These centers of knowing are sometimes analogized to the Trinity, but I’ll use head, heart, and body here, and trust that the wisdom of God is present in all of those places. ↩︎
- There is a growing body of research connecting self-silencing of emotions and chronic emotional stress to autoimmune disease, particularly in women. ↩︎



0 Comments